English Arabic Armenian Azerbaijani Chinese (Simplified) Chinese (Traditional) Czech Danish Dutch Estonian Filipino Finnish French Galician Georgian German Greek Hindi Hungarian Icelandic Indonesian Italian Japanese Korean Latvian Lithuanian Malay Maltese Norwegian Persian Polish Portuguese Russian Slovak Slovenian Spanish Swedish Thai Turkish Ukrainian Vietnamese

Cargolux et al cashback from cartel court

LUXEMBOURG: December 16, 2015. The General Court of the European Union has annulled fines of €790 million imposed in 2010 on 10 major airlines by the European Commission for alleged cartel behavior.

In addition to a €79.9 million refund for Cargolux, Air France-KLM is due €182.9 million, KLM a further €124.4 million, BA will get €104 million, Martinair €29.5 million and Cathay Pacific €57 million.

The decision to fine the carriers followed an investigation by the Commission into alleged air cargo collusion after a whistleblower move by Lufthansa Cargo and Swiss International Airlines in 2005.

Cargolux 45 yearsIn reaching its judgment the Court said the Commission had a responsibility to make the operative part of any decision "clear and precise" and a company subject to any penalties must be in a position to understand why.

According to the Commission, the operative part of its decision mentions four infringements relating to different periods and routes. Whereas some of the infringements were found to have been committed by all the carriers concerned, others were found to have been committed by a more limited group of airlines.

Despite this, the Commission concluded there was one single and continuous worldwide infringement covering all the routes by all the carriers and imposed fines on all of them with the exception of Lufthansa and Swiss that were granted immunity.

In appealing to the Court, the airlines fined by the Commission claimed the decision did not allow them to determine the nature and scope of their alleged infringements, and therefore there was a contradiction between the grounds and the operative part of the decision.

The Court agreed - noting the carriers were held liable for the entirety of the infringement with no distinction made between the routes they operated and those they didn't.

The Court added that the grounds for the Commission's decision "contain assessments which are difficult to reconcile with the existence of a single cartel covering all of the routes referred to in the operative part". The resultant inconsistencies, it declared, "were liable to infringe the applicant's rights of defense and prevent the Court from exercising its power of review".

The Court has ordered the Commission to pay the airlines' court costs and has given it two months to appeal the annulment decision.

News

Written on 23/06/2017, 20:22
xpo-hit-by-port-strikeLOS ANGELES/LONG BEACH: June 23, 2017. Port and rail drivers working as independent contractors for XPO Cartage, part of XPO Logistics, began a strike...
Written on 21/06/2017, 22:44
more-disasters-but-less-moneyGENEVA: June 21, 2017. The United Nations says it needs US$23.5 billion in 2017 to provide humanitarian assistance to a record 141 million people in 37...
Written on 21/06/2017, 20:19
switzerland-remains-the-world-s-most-innovative-countryGENEVA: June 21, 2017 – Switzerland, Sweden, the Netherlands, U.S. and UK are the world's most innovative countries according to a new report by produced...
Written on 21/06/2017, 16:53
fedex-and-ups-among-best-civic-minded-u-s-companiesSEATTLE: June 21, 2017. FedEx and UPS are among the 50 most community-minded companies in the United States according to the latest 'Civic 50' list from...
Written on 16/06/2017, 20:37
eu-commercial-drones-by-2019-says-commissionBRUSSELS: June 16, 2017. The European Commission says commercial drones flying in a 'U-Space' under 150 meters from the ground will be operate in the EU...
Written on 16/06/2017, 19:00
collaboration-and-compromise-key-to-uk-trade-futurePARIS: June 15, 2017. The OECD is forecasting a 1.7 percent rise in UK GDP this year and just 1.0 percent in 2018 as uncertainty rises of Britain not...
Written on 16/06/2017, 15:01
amazon-to-buy-bricks-and-mortar-grocer-for-us-13-7-billionSEATTLE: June 16, 2017. Amazon has agreed to buy Texas-based Whole Foods Market (WFM) for US$13.7 billion including debt. WFM reported Q2 2017 net sales...
Written on 15/06/2017, 20:35
amazon-to-sell-cars-in-britain-delivered-by-emirates-skycargoLONDON: June 14, 2017. Amazon is hiring automotive experts as a prelude to selling cars in the UK according to eCommerce delivery company Parcel...
Written on 12/06/2017, 16:13
qatar-airways-adds-dublin-as-profits-riseDOHA, Qatar: June 12, 2017. Despite continued uncertainty in Qatar following political and economic sanctions imposed by neighboring GCC countries, Qatar...
Written on 09/06/2017, 16:35
spanish-port-strike-continuesBARCELONA: June 09, 2017. Some 6,000 Spanish dockworkers are expected to continue their strike action until June 24 unless a meeting between their union...
Written on 07/06/2017, 01:08
we-are-still-in-say-u-s-states-and-businessesWASHINGTON, DC: June 05, 2017. Ignoring Donald Trump, 1,219 governors, mayors, businesses, investors, colleges and universities in the U.S. have declared...
Written on 06/06/2017, 19:35
iata-repeats-call-for-trade-freedomCANCUN, Mexico: June 06, 2017. IATA's 73rd annual general meeting has called on governments to implement the World Trade Organization's (WTO) Trade...
Written on 05/06/2017, 20:34
qatar-cargo-to-operate-perishables-airliftDOHA: June 05, 2017. The Qatar Cargo weekly A330 freighter service to London Heathrow that began on June 03 could be part of a food airlift if the Saudia...
Written on 01/06/2017, 20:52
u-s-not-so-competitiveLAUSANNE, Switzerland: May 31, 2017. The United States is no longer one of the top three competitive countries in the world according to a new 63-country...
Written on 01/06/2017, 18:57
rickmers-group-files-insolvency-following-bank-moveHAMBURG: June 01, 2017. The Rickmers Group has declared insolvency following the rejection by HSH Nordbank of a proposed financial restructuring. Last...
Written on 01/06/2017, 14:07
exxon-mobil-low-carbon-future-as-trump-pulls-climate-plugBOSTON, MA: June 01, 2017. As expected, Donald Trump has announced the United States is withdrawing from the Paris Agreement on climate change, despite...
Written on 26/05/2017, 16:16
powerful-future-ahead-for-madagascarPORT LOUIS, Mauritius. May 24, 2017. Volga-Dnepr Airlines has now completed a series of flights begun in March to deliver power generators from Mauritius...
Written on 25/05/2017, 20:07
rhinos-return-to-rwandaAKAGERA, Rwanda: May 25, 2017. Ten years after the Eastern black rhino disappeared from Rwanda following decades of poaching, 19 animals have now taken up...
Written on 25/05/2017, 18:33
port-everglades-gets-expansion-go-aheadPORT EVERGLADES, FL: May 24, 2017. Port Everglades is to invest US$437.5 million to add new berths for larger cargo vessels and install crane rail...
Written on 24/05/2017, 20:42
hapag-lloyd-takes-a-big-step-with-uascHAMBURG: May 24, 2017. Hapag-Lloyd and the United Arab Shipping Company (UASC) have completed their merger. Shareholders at the annual general meeting on...

- powered by Quickchilli.com -